Policy Watch

Fairer Redistricting Initiatives Advance in Michigan and Ohio



Joyce grantees in Michigan and Ohio have played integral roles advancing policy for fairer implementation of legislative districts for all citizens in those states. These policy shifts come at a time when equitable redistricting—the once-a-decade process of redrawing legislative districts in the year following the census—has become fraught with partisan politics nationwide and left many voters potentially disenfranchised.

In Michigan, the new process, shepherded by the Michigan Independent Citizens Redistricting Commission, required map-makers to listen to community input and dismantled the previous process that allowed lawmakers to gerrymander district maps to overwhelmingly favor their party. Lawmakers were excluded from the new mapmaking process and the independent commission created new districts that are no longer skewed to artificially favor one political party over the other. In Ohio, the work of advocates like the League of Women Voters’ of Ohio was paramount in a pair of recent state supreme court decisions striking down as unconstitutional the partisan, lawmaker-drawn congressional and state assembly maps that heavily favored one political party.

The actions in both states still face legal challenges, which is common during the first time using a new process. Several other Great Lakes states, including Minnesota and Wisconsin, are also in the process of proposing new legislative maps that could ultimately be approved by state courts.

Still, while the redistricting process is imperfect, accountability and adherence to implementing policy can serve as strong examples for other states, advocates said.

“My hope is that, as a package, as a whole process, people can see Michigan and us having gone through this entire cycle and having come out the other end so successfully,” said Nancy Wang, executive director of Voters Not Politicians in a recent New York Times story. “that there are going to be pieces of our model that get adopted in other states.”

About The Joyce Foundation

Joyce is a nonpartisan, private foundation that invests in evidence-informed public policies and strategies to advance racial equity and economic mobility for the next generation in the Great Lakes region.

Related Content

Grantee Spotlight

Democracy Desk: “Unlock Civics” Advocates Expanding Voting Rights and Civic Education for Incarcerated Community Members

Two Joyce Democracy grantees, Chicago Votes and Chicago Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights, discuss their inspiring voting rights work in Illinois.

Policy Watch

Landmark settlement in lawsuit against Wisconsin fraudulent electors scheme

Two Joyce Foundation grantees recently reached settlement agreements in a legal case seeking to hold accountable individuals who played a key role in a scheme to submit a fraudulent slate of electors from Wisconsin in the 2020 presidential election.

Policy Watch

Democracy Advocates Achieve Fair Maps Victory in Wisconsin

Wisconsin achieves a huge victory with the enactment of fair maps. This victory for Wisconsin voters is the result of many years of advocacy and litigation by nonpartisan watchdog groups that took the fight for fair maps to the Supreme Court.


Democracy Desk: Key themes to watch this election year

the first installment of Democracy Desk, an election year series highlighting key issues throughout the Great Lakes region, and spotlighting the work of our grantee partners to ensure free, fair, accessible, safe, and trusted elections.


Joyce Democracy Grantees Ramp Up Great Lakes Voter Education, Protection Efforts

Democracy nonpartisan organizations working to get out the vote in Great Lakes region.

In The Media

How a Philanthropic Bet on Violence Intervention Is Winning Public Dollars

State, local, and city agencies are investing about $150 million this year in a variety of community violence-intervention strategies that philanthropy is road-testing. Read more about how the Joyce Foundation and others are stepping in to fund CVI work.

The Chronicle of Philanthropy


Poll Gauges Public Attitudes toward Political Violence in the United States

The Joyce Foundation, Trusted Elections Fund, and The Klarman Family Foundation initiated a public opinion research project exploring the public’s view of, and reaction to, political violence and extremism.


The Foundation's statement on the Bruen case ruling

The Supreme Court’s ruling today in the Bruen case will make communities across America less safe. A large and growing body of evidence demonstrates that the mere presence of a firearm increases the risk of injury and death.