Research Reports

Examining inequitable water debt in Chicago



Header image courtesy of Elevate.

Chicago’s lowest income households are the most burdened with high water bills, paying almost 10% of their income to water, a threshold considered too high, with majority Black neighborhoods having water debt 10 times higher than majority white neighborhoods, according to a new, Joyce-funded report authored by Elevate Chicago and the Metropolitan Planning Council for the City of Chicago.

The City of Chicago Water Affordability Analysis examined millions of city residential water bills between 2015 and 2020, outlining how non-metered homes—concentrated in majority-Black neighborhoods—pay more for water annually than metered customers. In 2019, for example, non-metered customers paid $500 more annually than customers in metered homes. The report found that 20 percent of delinquent bills come from customers more than a year in arrears.

“Water bill affordability is a racial equity issue, with accounts in majority Black, Hispanic, and Asian-populated tracts less likely to be metered, more likely to have leaks…and facing on average a higher burden while using comparatively less water than accounts in majority white (non-Hispanic) tracts,” the report states.

The report also includes several other key findings designed to help the City of Chicago equitably address water affordability, bill burden, shutoffs, plumbing issues and customer service, including:

  • Multifamily buildings, particularly 2-5 unit buildings and 12+ unit buildings, see the highest rates of nonpayment and increases in debt over time, and 2-unit buildings have the highest average burden.
  • Because of unpaid balances accruing over time, payment arrangements are mostly insufficient to address nonpayment.
  • Other charges composing the water bill (garbage fee, taxes) contribute to high bills and should be factored into the city’s strategy to improve water affordability.

Among its other recommendations to the city, the report encourages enhanced outreach and enrollment in state and city water bill assistance programs, more flexible payment arrangements, and implementing universal metering for all residential accounts in Chicago.

Read more about water debt in Chicago from our grantee partners at WBEZ here.

About The Joyce Foundation

Joyce is a nonpartisan, private foundation that invests in evidence-informed public policies and strategies to advance racial equity and economic mobility for the next generation in the Great Lakes region.

Related Content

In The Media

Opinion: Lake Erie is a test for Northeast Ohio and its neighbors; we can ace it

Op-ed by the Foundation's Environment Co-director Elizabeth Cisar, Stephen Love of the Cleveland Foundation, and John Mitterholzer of the George Gund Foundation.

Crain's Cleveland Business

Grantee Spotlight

We the People of Detroit

We the People of Detroit is a grantee partner of Joyce’s Environment Program. Learn more about the organization here.

Policy Watch

Environmental Advocates Celebrate as Minnesota Pledges to become 100% Carbon-Free

Minnesota becomes the 22nd state nationwide to commit to 100 percent carbon-free electricity—a victory for Great Lakes region environmental and environmental justice organizations that, for many years, advocated for such policy.


A Year at EPA: Lessons Learned

Environment Program Co-Director Elizabeth Cisar recently returned to the Foundation after serving an 18-month stint as a senior advisor in the Office of Water at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.


University of Michigan Releases National Framework to Measure Energy Equity

The Energy Equity Project (EEP) at the University of Michigan School for Environment and Sustainability recently released the first national framework to comprehensively measure and advance energy equity.


The Joyce Foundation received the 2022 CGLR Great Lakes Changemaker Award

The Joyce Foundation received the 2022 Great Lakes Changemaker Award from the Council of the Great Lakes Region.


Joyce Foundation Statement on Supreme Court Ruling in West Virginia v. Environmental Protection Agency

The Supreme Court ruling in West Virginia v. EPA is a step backward in protecting the environment and public health. It limits the federal government’s ability to use the Clean Air Act to drive reductions in global warming pollution.

Policy Watch

Michigan Advocates Celebrate “Transformational” Environmental Investment

$5B bill infrastructure bill designed to improve drinking water, sewers, parks and other essential measures considered the largest and most beneficial environmental investment in Michigan in decades.